People may be stuck in what they think is a local maximum. I ditched emacs close to 20 years ago (for jEdit, later Sublime and finally IntelliJ) and have never regretted it in the slightest.
I don't want my editor to read usenet or play solitaire. I want it to edit text and surface useful contextual information, and otherwise stay out of the way and let me devote my mental energy to the task at hand and not futzing with the damn editor config.
I really want to use Orgmode (or maybe something like Neorg/Vimviki for vim), but the biggest issue with all of those things is that somehow, there still isn't a proper mobile app for any of them. No, I don't want a simple TODO app that uses Orgmode under the hood. I want an actual app for Orgmode, something which works like Obsidian or Logseq. (In fact, Logseq supports orgmode, but that support is very limited and sometimes incompatible with actual Orgmode)
I don't understand how there are so many passionate users of Orgmode yet apparently not a single one of them is a mobile developer who sometimes takes notes on their phone.
By contextual data I’m really just talking about things like being able to auto complete from it only the code base, but associated sql schemas as well. Or presenting code navigation as a sorted hierarchy of classes, functions, etc. Lazy human want computer do work.
What he wants is to connect his editor to an SQL database and have TAB completion in a string for keys and tables in that database. He wants to be able to traverse a codebase by classes rather than by file. Basically he wants Smalltalk.
> I ditched emacs close to 20 years ago (for jEdit, later Sublime and finally IntelliJ) and have never regretted it in the slightest.
In that time I've carried on using Emacs, and have regretted it several times ;)
However, Emacs has come on a lot. It's much easier to configure than it used to be, and LSP has brought its semantic features back into the range of other editors. Its text processing abilities have always been stellar and far outshone anything else I've tried.
I'm very happy I stuck with it. I've kept many years of muscle memory and tricks and avoided having to reconfigure 3 different editors. Plus there are killer features like magit and org-mode.
I don't want my editor to read usenet or play solitaire. I want it to edit text and surface useful contextual information, and otherwise stay out of the way and let me devote my mental energy to the task at hand and not futzing with the damn editor config.