Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sorry, but that’s nonsense.

I didn’t say “a century ago”, I said “for a century”

Local banks and credit unions still do it, competently enough to earn very high satisfaction ratings from their customers/members.

(And there are indeed still plenty of “housemaids and gas station attendants” so that was a weird aside anyway)



> Local banks and credit unions still do it, competently enough to earn very high satisfaction ratings from their customers/members.

Wrong question. If they were popular with their customers they wouldn't be small banks, they'd be big banks.

(The exception is that because of regulations, there's businesses that only small banks can get into, so it may help to appear to be small.)

> (And there are indeed still plenty of “housemaids and gas station attendants” so that was a weird aside anyway)

Do you live in India?


> If they were popular with their customers they wouldn't be small banks, they'd be big banks.

What? That’s not how businesses work. Businesses don’t grow indefinitely, they size themselves to fit an underserved niche. Pretty much every census region still has one or several local banks and one or several credit unions, all serving the needs of people and businesses underserved by larger banks. And they do very well. Too much growth would precisely undermine their edge in serving these customers, for exactly the reasons I outlined in my original comment.

> Do you live in India?

No.


> What? That’s not how businesses work. Businesses don’t grow indefinitely, they size themselves to fit an underserved niche.

You're posting on a forum for a startup accelerator. That's pretty good evidence against that.

Anyway, there is structural pressure against a credit union growing, but not a bank; it just wants to profit like everything else. Like I said, the US is unique in having small banks. Most countries don't.

> No.

Then where are you seeing live in servants?


> gas station attendants

Only when legally required by law, and you end up paying for it in the price and availability -- ever tried getting gas in Oregon after 9pm?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: