Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sure there's a difference, an XBox sucks.

Besides that? Not particularly. The input devices are worse, the underlying hardware and software is worse, the fact it only supports a measly 60hz at 4K^1 blows. I used to love XBoxes and have many great memories of my original and 360, but ever since the XBox One it's just been a bloated, slow PC with a bad interface front for Windows.

I own one because occasionally I like to play Halo 5. That's literally it.

[1]: What Microsoft calls 4K which is like 2560x1440 upscaled slightly on the vast majority of games.*



I'm not gonna disagree with your reasons for liking or disliking a gaming console. Gaming consoles are for fun, your preferences don't have to make logical sense. But...

     but ever since the XBox One it's just been a 
     bloated, slow PC with a bad interface front for Windows.
Huh? The original XBox and 360 were also slow (relative to higher-end PCs of their day) systems running Windows variants.


Yes but they didn't feel slow. The One does and so do it's iterations. They all run slow, download slow, and just feel sluggish to use. Even the Switch which is INCREDIBLY limited on the hardware front feels snappy and responsive.

Every console has always had worse hardware compared to a PC, that's a given, but almost all of them don't feel that way because the developers know the platform and can squeeze every last cycle out of the hardware. The One has NEVER felt nice to use. Ever.


That makes more sense, I guess. I've never used an XBOne so I don't have an opinion as to how responsive it feels.


It is truly awful. Menus take an atrocious amount of time to load, everything is buried several screens deep into massive UI elements that usually amount to huge boxes of solid color, the home screen itself seems to lag quite badly which is just embarrassing for a device that can also run Halo 5 at 2K/60hz without issue, is choking to death on a bunch of fucking boxes.


Yikes! And also, I really appreciate the clarification.


Yeah for sure man. I know a lotta PC guys give consoles shit (rightfully so :D) but I enjoy them too, my PS5 is the slickest thing I've ever used, and the switch is a remarkable little piece of kit, with some stumblings here and there, but yeah, between the severe dip in quality in the XBox One and subsequent iterations, and Microsoft's move to really amp up the experience for PC gaming on the XBox network, I just feel an XBox is a bad proposition these days. It's just a shitty PC that's locked down and you can't fix it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: