Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Very odd to me how so many comments here seem to be blaming the police for swatting and forgetting that there is some random evil asshole attempting to orchestrate violence against another person.


Is Swatting a thing outside of the US?

Would it be possible for some random evil asshat to execute violence via swatting if the swat police wasn't so trigger happy?

No?

Then maybe swat is the big problem.


Famously, the collapse of Kiwifarms was triggered by them carrying on their usual campaign of swatting against Keffals when she had gone to an address in Northern Ireland, whose police are much more savvy to threats.

You really don't hear about swatting being a thing in the UK because the police don't have nearly the same level of license and impunity for violence. So everytime there is such an incident it's national news.


Not really, no. People do sometimes call in bomb threats to skip school though.

The by far most common crime involving cops and phones is to call elderly people pretending to be cops to extort money. They usually spoof the caller ID of the local PD or even the emergency number itself in some cases.


Why not go one more level up in your abstraction and ask “why does SWAT exist?”. Why stop at the police?

Assholes doing evil are why SWAT units exist and evil assholes use SWAT to do evil.

The big problem is evil assholes.


Not to the same extent, since many places don't deploy such extreme violence for policing, but yes, that happens elsewhere.


Swatting requires more than someone wanting to orchestrate violence - swatting absolutely requires police to participate actively in the swatting. The person wouldn't be able to do this sort of violence if the police refused.


How on earth could a random evil asshole orchestrate violence against an innocent person via a SWAT team though?

Oh, yeah, SWAT teams are violent toward and kill innocent people.

That would seem to be a key issue that warrents some degree of blame.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: