Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Nobility implies sacrifice. Cassius, Brutus, et. al sacrificed nothing except the hard-fought stability and foundational reform that Caesar was in the process of providing. If honor can be accorded to jealous rentiers guarding latifundia and Old Money engaging in institutional revanchism, then yes, America should learn from history and what happens to tyrants given time.

As far as hamfisted comparisons between Trump to Caesar go, Trump is no Caesar. He lacks gall, youth, tribute, loyalty, and competence. The only connection he has is the theatricality of those that floundered in the wake of Caesar & Augustus.



> Cassius, Brutus, et. al sacrificed nothing

Bedsides their standing, wealth and lives?


Ceasar was a glory seeking political opportunist and a war criminal. You’re right the second part probably does not apply to Trump…

> hard-fought stability and foundational reform that Caesar was in the process of providing.

Yes just like any dictator. Augustus ended up learning from Caesars mistakes and at the built much more stable foundations than Caesar ever could.

Caesar was just a second Sulla. Obviously he was much less bloodthirsty and cruel from the perspective of his fellow Romans (Gauls and Germans are subhumans so who cares about them). However he suffered from the same savior/messiah complex that Sulla did, believing he alone could reform and save the republic. Well he didn’t and he couldn’t anyway..




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: