Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> In a venn diagram "pedestrians" and "car owners" would be nearly a perfect circle.

Nonsense. The ability to walk doesn't a pedestrian make" in the context of the discussion, and having to walk from the parking lot to the store and back isn't a pedestrian activity.

> Singling them out as opposing groups with conflicting interests isn't helpful.

I didn't decide of the historical events of a hundred years ago mate.

> America got to be car-centric not because of nefarious car companies or other special interests, it got to be car-centric because cars work very well for our use case. Consumers and voters (another near perfect Venn circle) have expressed their preference continuously for nearly a century.

Even worse, completely ahistorical, nonsense. Long-term infrastructural decisions are rarely decided directly by voters (as Robert Moses knew and leveraged), and furthermore can often be swayed by short terms concerns.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: