Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> If pressed I guess I’ll say it’s unlikely to be true. But that’s not the point.

The problem is expecting the dogma of a thousands years old tradition and book to be absolutely true. There are things in the Bible and Christianity that are basically tall tales. For example, I doubt Jesus was immaculately conceived, but it makes for a great story. People make up stories about remarkable people. I believe Jesus was a real person who had world-changing insights, but I'm afraid a lot of cruft has built up around him and been carried forward as literal truth.

The challenge for an individual is separating the wheat from the chaff.

Most of my thoughts on the matter are derived from Tolstoy's The Kingdom of God is Within You.



I didn't read it, but I listened to an audiobook version of TKOGIWY about a year ago on a long road trip. I must have missed something, because my take-away was that the author was propounding the merits of of passivism, and anti-authoritarianism. I thought it was tedious. I remember being disappointed.


It is very dense and in a philosophical style. I'm not surprised it was tedious as an audiobook. I'd like to read it again myself. My takeaway was that Tolstoy believed Christ had ushered in a new era for man, philosophically. The previous eras were:

1. man serves self and family

2. man serves state and country

3. man serves god

He believed many of our problems are due to most of us still being stuck at level 2 of existence. A man at level 3 is immune to the problems of a man at level 2. For example, they couldn't even compel Jesus w/ bodily harm. They killed him, and what good did it do them?

He also argued that the shift to level 3 is inevitable and already in progress.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: