Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What would be the modern approach to solving the same problem?


Municipal water sanitation

Fine for rat infested houses

Significant Fines and inspection for business especially live markets, food factories and mills

Citizen education program, such as encouraging cats, not leaving food around, inspecting homes for holes

Strict garbage collection. Fines for properties that leave garbage outdoors outside garbage collection days


Proper environmental hygiene:

- No hole for them to sneak into kitchens, etc

- No food left around for them to eat

- No place for them to hide and breed

That, and maybe rat-killing robots, equipped with computer vision, who won't cheat on you.


Aside from robotic death machines these are all preventative. Which is of course better, but only works if you aren't currently suffering.

Is there a modern solution to "my city is full of plague rats right now" other than evacuate?


The Alberta government started a rat free program in the 1950s. This article is fairly comprehensive:

https://www.alberta.ca/history-of-rat-control-in-alberta.asp...


With them eating crops, it might be difficult to achieve 'no food left around for them to eat'


There presumably aren't very many crops in Hanoi.


Quite a lot of land in Hanoi is dedicated to agriculture. Even Hong Kong has some farmland, for that matter.

According to one paper, about two decades ago, half of Hanoi province’s land was used for agriculture.¹ I don’t know the relation between the province and the city area. However, at table 4 there are supposedly 0.25 ha of agricultural land per household in the City Districts—more than in certain other areas in Hanoi province! A decline in the proportion of land dedicated to agriculture is likely to have occurred. But urban agriculture does not seem to have been eliminated. According to another (2010) article, the local government considers the growing of ‘modern’ vegetables (instead of less appealing rice—I don’t really understand this æsthetic preference) an important priority in preventing the city from looking outdated.² A reasonable number of farmers are interviewed. This suggests that a good number of urban farmers remained at least then. The most recent article I can find is from 2019, when the Asia Foundation published a post on their blog about a programme to assist local farmers.³

It’s very easy I think to forget that agriculture isn’t entirely squeezed out of highly urbanised Asian cities.I only realised recently that there were farms in Singapore: my relatives never mentioned them, even though they are always very eager to show me other parts of the city—possibly because they don’t know about them.

Returning to the original article, then, crops probably do pose a problem in controlling rat populations.

1: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/095624780301500...

2: https://journals.openedition.org/factsreports/464

3: https://asiafoundation.org/2019/07/17/going-green-urban-farm...


Huh. Well, learned something today; I'd never even have imagined this, particularly about Singapore!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: