Sure, and that's why I said I was assuming, but my (poorly communicated) intent was to question how unique your first name is, and how someone is squatting on it if it's a real account and maybe they have that name too?
I mean, it's probably not a big deal in this case. But if I had a github account that someone wanted and github just gave out my (personal?) info, I might feel a bit betrayed by them. I know, I shouldn't give them any info I really want private, but that doesn't mean I can't expect them to act responsibly with what I have given them. I just didn't want to state all that up front, because it assumes a lot about what happened when there wasn't a lot of detail provided.
It is nice when people can just make simple stuff happen though, I agree. It's just a hard line to walk, because you allow that and then you get stuff like the recent Twitter hack. It's hard for us to all have nice things and nice people that can help us because there really are a bunch of people out there to get you (or someone in a similar situation, at least). :/
They don't give you access to the account. They tombstone the old one and assign its handle to yours. So you get the other GitHub handle but your account retains its repos, its keys, etc and doesn't get mixed in with the other account.
Of course, if they just let you login to the other one that would be crazy business. You'd know the other guy's email for starters. But they don't.
It's all perfectly kosher. You just get the namespace.
Ah, they gave the account name. When you said "asked them for the guy" and "they just gave it to me", I was interpreting it as the guy's contact info and them just giving it to you, which is what was raising red flags for me. Yeah, it's much less problematic if they just let you use the name of a discontinued account (as long as the github single-sign-on stuff keys off an ID and not a name, which I assume it does).
Yeah sorry about that. Though it's funny. You can just scrape folks' repos to get their email anyway. They all include it in commits. Emails are better made public than kept private imho.
