Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> No one is stealing from you, they are stealing from a supermarket

Yes, well they're stealing from someone, aren't they? But of course, it's ok if someone steals from the heartless grocery store owner, isn't it? I feel as if you would have a different opinion if anybody was allowed to walk into your house without your permission and ransack your fridge (and anything else they felt that they "need").

The moral problem with theft isn't that it is illegal. The problem is that one person expended their own personal resources to create the good. The person has spent their own time, money, and/or intelligence to create some good that now has value. The thief, who has expended zero effort to create nothing, takes the fruit of the producer's labor for no work, on the basis of his "need". What kind of society does this produce, where you can take things from others solely on your basis of need?

You seem to be making the cliche mistake of associating morality with need. I hope one day you don't need to learn this isn't always correlated...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: